top of page
Sweet Surrender didn’t invent cupcakes but we did perfect them. Every delectable little cupcake is hand-crafted and made with the same care, attention, same high-quality ingredients as our legendary cakes…just smaller…and maybe a bit more fun.


One reason our cupcakes are so amazing is that they are fresh baked. That means that not every flavor is available every day. Please contact the store if you have a special request.  


Have you ever dreamed of chocolate?  If so, then this may be your favorite cupcake. Rich chocolate cake is filled with mascarpone cream filling. Topped with rich whipped cream and chocolate cake crumbles.


Our yummy Pink Champagne Cake dipped in White Chocolate Ganache, topped with a pink swirl frosting, sprinkles and a Frosted Animal Cracker .


Our classic, white cake mixed with colorful sprinkles topped with our rich, house-made buttercream and mixed sprinkles.


Available Sun, Mon, Tues

A sweet twist on a classic cupcake.  Our Rich chocolate cupcake base injected with our house buttercream, dipped in chocolate ganache with “Sweet” written on top.

Lemon Delight

Lemon lovers…you have found your ideal cupcake.  Lemon cupcake filled with lemon curd topping and whipped cream with lemon cake crumbles on top.

Lemon White Chocolate

Lemon lovers you are in for a treat.  Lemon cupcake with our lemon zest, white chocolate buttercream, topped with a gummy lemon slice.



​​Our nationally acclaimed Matterhorn cake is available every day as a cupcake.  This is also available as a mini-cupcake.


Pink Champagne

Our white cake flavored with pink champagne extract.  Our rich, house buttercream tinted pink on top with pink pearls.

Red Velvet

Red Velvet cake with mini chocolate chips baked in, iced with our house buttercream garnished with mini chocolate chips.


Rich Chocolate

​​Our Rich Chocolate cupcake frosted with our chocolate buttercream made with Guittard cocoa garnished with real chocolate Guittard sprinkles.  Also available as mini-cupcakes.


Available Wed, Thurs, Fri

No campfire needed.  Our Rich Chocolate cupcake with a graham cracker crust filled with marshmallow crème, dipped in our house made ganache, topped with a generous dollop of toasted fluffy meringue.


Strawberry Shortcake

Inspired by the Good Humor Strawberry Shortcake ice cream bar, we take our amazing strawberry cupcake with our house made creamy buttercream made with real butter and cream cheese and roll it a strawberry shortcake crumble.

White on White

White vanilla flavored with our house buttercream, sprinkled with crystal sugar.


Butterfinger Cheesecake

This is just a smaller version of our popular Butterfinger Cheesecake. It's proof that great things do come in small packages.


Lemon Cheesecake

Rich cream cheese filling topped with sweet lemon and creamy whipped cream.

Oreo Cheesecake

Our famous Oreo cake is transformed into a rich, creamy cheesecake cupcake.


Peanut Butter Cheesecake

This is the best of all good things—cream cheese, Reese’s peanut butter cups, whipped cream and you guessed it…more Reese’s on top.

Pumpkin Cheesecake


The holidays and pumpkin just go together. It only available for a short time but what better way reward yourself and loved ones during the holidays—pumpkin, cheesecake, Sweet Surrender.


Vanilla Cheesecake

Seasonal fresh fruit tops this cheesecake classic to create that wonderful balance of sweet and creamy.

bottom of page